The Journal of Education and Culture implements a rigorous peer-review process to uphold the publication of high-quality, impactful research. Each manuscript submitted to the journal undergoes a comprehensive evaluation by the editorial team and external reviewers. This process is designed to maintain the academic integrity and scholarly standards of the journal.

Initial Editorial Screening

All manuscripts are initially assessed by the editorial team to determine their alignment with the focus and scope of the Journal of Education and Culture. During this stage, the manuscript is evaluated for overall quality, clarity, and compliance with the journal’s submission guidelines. Manuscripts that do not meet these fundamental criteria are promptly rejected without proceeding to external review.

Double-Blind Peer Review

Manuscripts that successfully pass the initial screening are forwarded to at least two expert reviewers for a double-blind peer review. This approach ensures that both authors and reviewers remain anonymous, facilitating an impartial evaluation process. Reviewers are selected based on their expertise in the relevant subject area.

Review Timeline

Standard Review Time. Reviewers are expected to complete their evaluations within 2–3 weeks from the date of assignment.

Third Reviewer Appointment. In instances where the assessments of the initial reviewers significantly diverge, a third reviewer may be appointed to provide an additional evaluation.

Evaluation Criteria

Reviewers utilize a standardized manuscript evaluation form to assess submissions based on several criteria:

• The relevance and originality of the research.
• The rigor of the methodology and analysis.
• The clarity and coherence of the presentation.
• The contribution of the findings to the fields of education and culture.

Reviewers are required to treat all manuscript content as confidential and must not use or disclose any information obtained during the review process.

Editorial Decision

The final decision regarding each manuscript is made by the editorial team, guided by the feedback provided by the reviewers. Based on these evaluations, possible outcomes include:

Accept without revisions. The manuscript is deemed ready for publication in its current form.

Accept with minor revisions. The manuscript requires minor modifications that do not necessitate further review.

Accept with major revisions. Substantial changes are needed, and the revised manuscript will undergo a second round of review.

Reject. The manuscript is determined to be unsuitable for publication in the journal.

Authors are notified of the editorial decision along with detailed feedback from the reviewers. Authors of accepted manuscripts must revise their submissions following the comments provided by both reviewers and editors before proceeding to the final stages of publication.

This transparent and rigorous review process allows the Journal of Education and Culture to publish research that meets high academic standards, thereby making significant contributions to the fields of education and culture.

Author Guidelines

The following guidelines outline the requirements for submitting manuscripts to the Journal of Education and Culture. Authors must adhere to these guidelines to guarantee their manuscripts meet the journal's standards for submission, review, and publication. Non-compliance may result in the manuscript being returned for revision or rejection.

Manuscript Submission Types

The journal accepts the following types of submissions:

1. Review Articles.
• Minimum of 2,000 words.
• At least 50 references (80% primary literature, published within the last six years).
2. Research Articles. Includes case reports, commentaries, and brief research communications.
• Word count: 1,000–2,000 words.
• At least 30 references (80% primary literature, published within the last six years).

General Submission Requirements

• Manuscripts must be original and not under consideration by any other publication.
• Authors are required to declare any conflicts of interest and include funding acknowledgments where applicable.
• Manuscripts should conform to the journal's formatting and referencing style.

Manuscript Structure and Content

Authors should ensure their manuscripts are organized into the following sections:

1. Title Page
• Full title (maximum 12 words) in sentence case.
• Author information, including full names, academic titles, affiliations, and contact email.
• Indicate the corresponding author with an asterisk (*).
2. Abstract and Keywords
• Abstract (maximum 250 words) summarizing the study, including the introduction, methods, results, discussion, and conclusion.
• Provide 3–6 keywords reflecting the content of the article.
3. Introduction
• Clearly state the research problem, objectives, and relevance of the study.
• Include a concise literature review that highlights gaps in knowledge.
4. Methodology
• Detail the research design, participant selection (inclusion and exclusion criteria), and procedures followed.
• For quantitative studies, include statistical methods and tools.
• For qualitative studies, outline the theoretical framework, sampling approach, and data analysis method.
5. Results
• Present findings in a logical sequence using appropriate tables, graphs, and figures.
• Ensure figures and tables are properly numbered and referenced in the text.
• Supplementary materials (if any) should be submitted in a separate file.
6. Discussion
• Interpret results in the context of the research objectives and existing literature.
• Address the implications of findings, limitations of the study, and recommendations for future research.
7. Conclusion
• Provide a concise summary of findings and their significance.
8. Acknowledgments
• Mention funding sources, institutional support, and any individuals who contributed to the research but do not qualify as authors.
9. References
• Follow the Vancouver style for references, numbered in the order of appearance.
• Use reference management software like Mendeley or EndNote.
• Ensure 80% of references are from primary sources published within the last 10 years.
10. Supplementary Materials

• Additional datasets, appendices, or figures may be submitted to support the manuscript.

Formatting Guidelines

• Use single spacing with a 12-point Times New Roman font.
• All tables, figures, and illustrations must be embedded within the text at the appropriate locations.
• Manuscripts must be submitted in one of the following formats: Microsoft Word, RTF, or Open Office.

Submission and Processing Fees

• Regular edition articles: Rp. 250,000 publication fee.
• Supplementary editions: Additional "fast-track review" fee of Rp. 250,000.

Copyright and Permissions

• Authors are responsible for securing permissions for copyrighted material, including figures, tables, or text excerpts.
• Reproduced content must be appropriately credited and accompanied by proof of permission from copyright holders.

Ethical Considerations

• Research involving human participants must include an ethics approval statement and informed consent declaration.
• Authors must disclose any financial or non-financial conflicts of interest.

Privacy Statement

The names and email addresses provided during registration will only be used for the purposes of this journal and will not be shared with any third parties.

Manuscript Submission

Submissions are managed through the journal's online platform. Authors must register and log in to upload their manuscripts and supporting documents.